The Seven Phases of American Political Party Systems and What’s Next

America’s political parties are overdue for a major realignment. They have undergone six historical phases in the nation’s history.

    • The First Political Party System — consisting of the Federalists, created by Alexander Hamilton of New York, and the Democratic-Republican Party, created by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison of Virginia — lasted from 1792 to 1824 (36 years).
    • The Second Political Party System — consisting of the Democratic Party, led by Andrew Jackson of Tennessee, and the Whig Party, assembled by Henry Clay — lasted from just 1828 until 1854 (26 years).
    • The Third Political Party System — consisting of the anti-slavery Republican Party of the North and the segregationist Democratic Party of the South, lasted from 1856 to 1890s (34-36 years).
    • The Fourth Political Party System, from the 1890s to 1932 (42 years), was dominated on the national level by the Republican Party, except for when Teddy Roosevelt split the Republicans in 1912 with his Bull Moose Party, leading to the election of Woodrow Wilson that year and in 1916. This era paralleled the progressive era.
    • The Fifth Political Party System, from 1932 to 1968 (36 years), was dominated on the national level by the Democratic Party New Deal Coalition, except for the election of the non-partisan national hero, Gen. Dwight Eisenhower, in 1952 and 1956, combined with closely contested Congressional elections until the Democratic landslide of 1958.
    • Political scientists disagree on when the Sixth Political Party System or realignment solidified. The consistently solid Democratic South was shattered in 1964, when Deep South states voted for Republican Barry Goldwater, though he lost in a landslide. This broke up the New Deal Coalition of white working-class voters and minorities. The “solid South” was no longer reliably Democratic.
    • The period 1968-1976 was transitional.  The third party campaign of segregationist George Wallace won 12 percent of the vote in 1968 appealing to disaffected racist Democrats, or Dixiecrats.  Richard Nixon eeked out a victory with 42 percent of the vote against Minnesota Democrat Hubert Humphrey, but still faced large Democratic majorities in Congress. Nixon adopted a “Southern Strategy” to appeal to Wallace voters in the midterm election of 1970 and the presidential election of 1972. The Watergate scandal and Nixon’s resignation gave Democrats a chance to rebuild their old Solid South coalition, without the racism, which they did with overwhelming congressional victories in 1974, and by nominating Jimmy Carter for president in 1976 and appealing to white Christians, especially in the Bible Belt, and African Americans.
    • Ronald Reagan ushered in a transformation in political party voting patterns in 1980. Deep South and Midwestern states have voted consistently Republican for president since 1980. At the least, a realignment has occurred with a majority of white males consistently choosing Republican presidential candidates and minorities consistently choosing Democratic presidential candidates. For details, see my review of Jon Ward’s book on the fight that broke the Democratic Party.
    • An Era of Divided Government (1968-2016, or 48 years): Despite a succession of Republican presidents (Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Bush 41, and Bush 43),  none had the coattails to bring fully Republican Congresses to power with them. The House of Representatives remained in solidly Democratic hands until 1994. Then, following the narrow election of Democrat Bill Clinton, Republicans took control of the House of Representatives for the first time since 1946. Bush 43 endured an almost evenly divided Congress. Then, in 2006, Democrats swept congressional elections and took full control of both the House and the Senate. This Democratic congressional dominance continued for four years, through the first two years of Barack Obama’s presidency, allowing him to achieve major accomplishments in his first two years. Then, in a backlash against the Obama presidency, in 2010, his party lost 63 seats in the House in 2010, and their majority, and barely maintained a 51-seat majority in the Senate. Four years later, in 2014, Republicans made sweeping gains in both the House and the Senate, controlling both chambers. In 2018, with Republican Donald Trump in the White House, Democrats made sweeping gains in the House of Representatives.
    • One-party Rule Creates Backlash: Actions of the majority party during unified one-party government — from 1976-1980, when Jimmy Carter was president; 1992-1994, when Bill Clinton was president; and 2008-2010 when Barack Obama was president, created a passionate backlash from Republicans and the loss of at least one congressional chamber by Democrats. This 38-year pattern continued in 2018 when President Trump and the Republicans lost control of the US House. So the pattern now continues for 40 years. If history is a guide, Democrats could win the White House and both houses of Congress in a landslide in 2020, but that might create a backlash in which Republicans take back at least one house of Congress in 2022 or 2026.
    • What’s Next? We are now facing a major political party realignment and seventh political party system. If the previous systems lasted a minimum of 26 years and a maximum of 42 years, we are due for a major party realignment.  With white males and conservative evangelicals representing declining blocks of voters, the Republican Party will clearly have to build new coalitions if it hopes to win national elections in the future. This could mean, in order to survive as a national party, it will have to reach a compromise on immigration and strengthen appeals to Hispanics, African Americans, non-religious and female voters. In the short run, this could infuriate their white male base, who feel abandoned and resentful of new cultural norms.
    • Democrats may be able to win a national election or two with appeals to identity politics. They will certainly not pick two white males to run on their 2020 ticket as the Republicans are currently slated to do with Trump and Pence.  Democrats want to send a message that they are the party of equal opportunity for women and minorities. But this is probably not a sustainable long-term strategy once Republicans recognize they can play identity politics, too, and put forth female candidates (such as Nikki Haley) to neutralize women’s issues, and minority candidates to neutralize immigration and racial voting.
    • Identity politics eventually create resentments because Americans like to judge people as individuals. Identity politics eventually produces the non-partisan retort, “I’m not opposed to women or African American leaders, I’m just opposed to this woman (Hillary Clinton/Nikki Haley) or this African American (Barack Obama/Ben Carson).”
    • Watch carefully for signs of a political party realignment, where previously predictable states switched alliances. There are hints in Kansas, where the governor is now a Democrat and state legislators are switching parties; in Alabama where Democrat Doug Jones won a Senate race in 2017; in Texas, Georgia, and Florida, where progressive Beto O’Rourke almost beat Ted Cruz in the race for senator from Texas; African Americans Andrew Gullum in Florida and Stacey Abrams in Georgia, ran strong races for governor.
    • 2016 was a year of political transition. Despite controlling both Houses of Congress 2017-18, Republicans had little to show the voters in terms of legislative accomplishments. If Democrats had won the presidency in 2016, they would also have little to show voters in terms of legislative accomplishment because they still faced a Republican Congress.
    • Republican governing coalition is fragile. Since Republicans won both the presidency and the Congress in 2016, but with a minority of the popular vote, their governing coalition is fragile. Donald Trump’s base of support is less than 40 percent of the electorate.
    • America is ripe for a one-term presidency. We haven’t had one for 24 years (1988-1992), the longest period in presidential history.
    • Read more about the emergence of the seventh political party system on Quora.com and other sites.

Drill Deeper:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: